Jennie Garth may have announced she’s leaving the revived 90210, but she’s not gone for good—at least not if onscreen half-sis Jessica Stroup has anything to do with it!

“There’s no saying she’s never going to come back,” Stroup recently told us. “She’s my sister. She will come back…I’m going to make it happen!”

But getting Kelly Taylor back to West Bev isn’t all Stroup’s character, Silver, has to worry about. She still has plenty of high school dramz going on, including a juicy love triangle with ex-beau Dixon (Tristan Wilds) and campus heartthrob/player Teddy (Trevor Donovan).

So, we’re dying to know: who does Silver really want to be with?

“It’s a tough call, but I think right now, deep down, Silver really wants to be with Teddy,” Stroup said.

Ironically, Stroup says she didn’t exactly welcome Donovan when he joined the cast. “When Trevor first started, I was like, ‘I don’t know about this guy—I’m not sure,’” she said. “It was literally like art imitating life and life imitating art. At first I thought he was stepping on our territory, but I’m actually having a blast with him.

“He’s such a good guy,” Stroup continued. “His character is finding his way to be a good guy as well.”